Forum:Ruling on nicknames
| Report post
|
I think there should be a rule on nicknames, they should be simple and catchy, but not too wordy, over-dramatic, or have too much emphasis on the "scariness" of the logo. I've seen a lot of logos here have too many nicknames, most of them are wordy, redundant, or too specific, and I doubt anyone but the writer used the nicknames anyway. A while ago I removed a nickname from the Bum Motion Pictures (South Korea) page that referenced bum as in butt, even though it wouldn't make any sense in a South Korean context anyway. I apologize if this has been discussed before and/or if there's already a rule on this, but I skimmed the rules page and there's none. |
| Report post
|
This is probably an unpopular opinion, but I feel the whole thing of having nicknames as part of logo description is kinda redundant. I'm pretty sure in most cases nobody ever uses the 'nicknames' of a logo - I don't think I've even seen people call it 'Ultra Majestic Tower' or 'The Searchlights V' in casual conversation, they just call it the '1994 20th Century Fox Logo'. for instance. Sure, there are some cases where nicknames are used enough to the point of being tied to a logo, say the 'V of Doom', but that could easily fit in the Editor's Note. At the very least, we should stick with 1-3 simple nicknames for a logo at most, some I've seen have 12, only like 1 that ever gets use. |
| Report post
|
I get what you all are saying, and I agree. Personally, I don't think nicknames should be abolished, but I do agree that there should be a limit on both the amount of them on a page, and the kinds they are (things like "The Personification of All That is X" or super-super-loooooong names [i.e. pretty much every page with a "rip-off logo" on it]? Yeah, those all gotta go). |
| Report post
|
Yes! We need a nickname limit. Too many nicknames cause clutter. Plus the super long ones get annoying. |
| Report post
|
Thinking of it, I think we should keep only the most widespread/used ones. |
| Report post
|
Here's another example, from the current Universal logo: "CGI Globe III", "100th Anniversary Globe", "Rotating Letters IV", "Majestic Globe", "100 Years of Universal", "Comcast Globe", "Centennial Globe", "Earth Globe VII", "Globes Through the Ages II", "Anniversary Globe II", "Happy Anniversary, Universal! II", "Universal's 100th", "Happy 100th, Universal!", "Century Globe", "Comcast Globe" I think it can be reduced to : "CGI Globe III", "100 Years of Universal", "Comcast Globe" Do you think this should be reduced? |
| Report post
|
Looks good to me! The nicknames that should go are definitely the ones that are repetitive and don't describe the logo well like the "Rotating Letters" one. |
