AVID:Requests for Comment: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added

Inline

Revision as of 07:18, 6 February 2023

Requests for Comment

Welcome to AVID's Requests for Comment page.

Shortcut: AVID:RfC

Requests for Comment (RfCs) are a way to gather community feedback and consensus on certain proposals, ideas, and issues which require the community's approval and assent in order to be applied.

Guidelines

RfCs should be opened about matters concerning the wiki as a whole, such as policy changes, enabling and disabling extensions, and features and ideas which would have significant effect on the wiki as a whole. Do not use this page to start discussions on page-specific matters, such as merges, splits, single category renames or deletions, except where a dispute pertaining to a single page is so significant that discussion on the article talk page has failed to effectively resolve it.
Once a proposal is created, it will automatically be added to the list of drafted proposals. When a proposal has been submitted for review, it will automatically move to the submitted requests list. Once approved by two staff members, it will be manually moved by a bureaucrat to the open list. Closed proposals will automatically be moved to the closed list.
If the drafted proposal has been rejected by two staff members and left with no revisions within the next seven days, it may be closed as failed.
Voters are given four options to submit their input or comments in the proposal: support, abstain, oppose, and comment. The latter is used to ask questions, provide new ideas to add onto the proposal, etc. Comments are not an alternative voting option. When writing your reasoning, please be sure to behave in a civil, courteous manner per user conduct guidelines.
Proposals, both drafted and open, are typically closed by a bureaucrat after seven days. However, an administrator, moderator or other suitable member of site staff may close it prematurely in the event that:
- The proposal is invalid, and is in violation of the above guideline.
  - Additionally, if the proposal is a violation of site rules, the proposal will be deleted and administrative action may be taken against your account.
- Another ongoing proposal has the same purpose as the one created.
- The author has made a comment stating that they want to retract the ongoing proposal. Please note that you may not close your own proposal without administrative approval.
- After two days, if there are 10 votes supporting or opposing a proposal, and there are no competing votes, the request is subject to be closed under the snowball clause. Additionally, in the case where a proposal gains 20 votes supporting or opposing it with no competing votes in its first day, the proposal may be closed immediately without the two-day grace period.
When a proposal is in the process of being drafted or voted, edits related to the RFC should not be made prematurely.
Please refrain from using punctuation marks (".", "!", "?", etc.) in the title of your proposal. This is for the following reasons:
- Because of the way Discord parses links, some links with these marks will instead lead to a 404 error page for those trying to view your proposal from our server.
- On a larger scale, using page titles to phrase your proposal as a sentence or a question is unnecessary for the proposal in question, and is therefore heavily discouraged. Proposals shall only be titled with the action it seeks to achieve, without having to add punctuation at the end, or phrasing it like a question.

How to submit a proposal

To submit a new proposal, enter a page title for the proposal that you are planning to submit in the text box below and click the "Create or edit" button. From there, enter the title of your proposal in the Request title field and, in the Description field below, type out what your proposal is about and what it'll aim to do once passed. Make sure to be as clear and concise as possible with the details of your proposal so that the community will know what exactly they will be voting on. When you are ready to submit your proposal, click "Save page".

Create a new proposal

Open requests

Closed requests

2023

Passed proposals

Failed proposals

@@ Line 8: / Line 8: @@
 *[[/Have Different Fonts Implemented on AVID/]]
 *[[/Featured Videos/]]
-*[[/Ban RfC votes with no writing/]]
 *[[/Add "Investigation Needed" as an Availability tier/]]
 *[[/Can You Put All "Legacy" On All AVID Pages?/]]
@@ Line 43: / Line 42: @@
 '''Failed proposals'''
+*[[/Ban RfC votes with no writing/]]
 *[[/Why do we want the old AVID name "CLG Wiki" back?/]]
 *[[/let's add 13 new fonts/]]