Failed proposals
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
== Closed requests == |
== Closed requests == |
||
<tabber> |
<tabber> |
||
2024= |
|||
'''Failed proposals''' |
|||
*[[/Remove "Logo-Related Sins Given in CinemaSins" page/]] |
|||
|-| |
|||
2023= |
2023= |
||
'''Passed proposals''' |
'''Passed proposals''' |
||
*[[/Logo Misconceptions/]] |
|||
<dpl> |
|||
*[[/Allow error screens on the wiki/]] |
|||
category=Passed Requests for Comment |
|||
*[[/Allow swear words for company names/film titles/]] |
|||
uses=Template:Archive top |
|||
*[[/Notability guidelines/]] |
|||
ordermethod=firstedit |
|||
*[[/Franchise bumpers, should we have them or not?/]] |
|||
order=descending |
|||
*[[/Discontinue/Remove POV Terms/]] |
|||
shownamespace=false |
|||
*[[/Remove ALL uses of the term "Clip-On"./]] |
|||
replaceintitle=?Requests for Comment/?, |
|||
*[[/Rename "Clip-on Library"/]] |
|||
</dpl> |
|||
*[[/Creating A Page To List Depricated Features/]] |
|||
*[[/Rename "Logo/Bumper/ID/whatever" section to "Visuals"/]] |
|||
*[[/Music/Sounds section revamp/]] |
|||
*[[/Replace all mentions of UK's Fair Dealing system with the US's Fair Use system/]] |
|||
*[[/Standardise all dates/]] |
|||
*[[/Wiki history article/]] |
|||
*[[/Since most production logos for companies with multiple names have their own pages for each company, why not do the same for bumpers?/]] |
|||
*[[/Have the "Main" button on the PageButtons template show multiple pages if on a page where a warning or bumper is used by multiple companies/]] |
|||
*[[/Availability proposals/]] |
|||
*[[/Introduce film leaders/]] |
|||
*[[/Implement a definitive AVID logo system/]] |
|||
*[[/Allow in-credit notices that are accompanied by a sound element/]] |
|||
*[[/Make changes to the 2020 WB logo description/]] |
|||
*[[/Add a Logo Identification section in the forums/]] |
|||
*[[/Test cards for the Audiovisual Identity Database/]] |
|||
*[[/Screen ALL future RfCs/]] |
|||
*[[/Include audio files of specific logo soundtracks on the site/]] |
|||
*[[/"Project:" namespace/]] |
|||
*[[/Add Request a Project to the sidebar/]] |
|||
*[[/AVIDProjects: group collaborations to improve the wiki/]] |
|||
*[[/Expand the mascots' appearances and roles/]] |
|||
*[[/Discontinue use of the Rollbacker role/]] |
|||
*[[/Introduce news intros/]] |
|||
*[[/Add TV Rating Bumpers/Advisories/]] |
|||
*[[/A question?/]] |
|||
*[[/AVID logo refresh/]] |
|||
*[[/Lower the edit threshold for the Moderator Extension/]] |
|||
*[[/Logos with Music by Categories/]] |
|||
*[[/Newly redesigned Tutorial Guide/]] |
|||
*[[/A poll section/]] |
|||
*[[/General UI refresh (Created on behalf of Compooper)/]] |
|||
*[[/Change "??? Logo" to "??? Tag" for commercial tags/]] |
|||
*[[/April Fools' Day 2023 Proposal/]] |
|||
*[[/Include VT clocks on the site/]] |
|||
*[[/Sidebar and footer refresh concept/]] |
|||
*[[/Renaming "Anti-Piracy Advices" pages and categories/]] |
|||
*[[/Links to Logopedia articles on pages/]] |
|||
*[[/Clarify Who can close a proposal/]] |
|||
*[[/Implement the Moderation extension/]] |
|||
*[[/Include splash screens on the site/]] |
|||
*[[/Blu-ray screensaver logos/]] |
|||
*[[/Guidelines for removing blank sections/]] |
|||
*[[/Change Featured Image Nominations/]] |
|||
*[[/Add links to logos described in "same as X logo of Y" pointers./]] |
|||
*[[/Reformat some section lists/]] |
|||
*[[/Image tracking categories/]] |
|||
*[[/Expand AVID:Copyrights/]] |
|||
*[[/What should we do with Requests for Rollback?/]] |
|||
*[[/Add a time limit to featured image proposals/]] |
|||
*[[/Change Lifespan Dates to the Initial Start and End Dates/]] |
|||
*[[/Use MDY and DMY date formats accordingly/]] |
|||
*[[/Revise criteria for SNOW closure/]] |
|||
*[[/Introduce the "Moderator" Role/]] |
|||
*[[/Add "Investigation Needed" as an Availability tier/]] |
|||
*[[/Have Different Fonts Implemented on AVID/]] |
|||
*[[/Featured Videos/]] |
|||
*[[/Singular fictional companies page/]] |
|||
*[[/Logo Urban Legends/]] |
|||
*[[/Separate name changes into their own pages and connect them with Chronology template/]] |
|||
*[[/Logo lifespan cleanup/]] |
|||
*[[/Change RfC Voting Icons/]] |
|||
*[[/The Jeff Question/]] |
|||
*[[/Seperate huge variants of logos with tabbers/]] |
|||
*[[/MergeSection and SplitSection templates + rewrite Split template/]] |
|||
*[[/Remove the Home Entertainment Bumpers section/]] |
|||
*[[/PageButtons design refresh/]] |
|||
*[[/New designs for wiki message boxes/]] |
|||
*[[/Restructure the RfC Voting System/]] |
|||
*[[/International English spelling/]] |
|||
*[[/Have the new mascots appear on all the sections/]] |
|||
*[[/Restructure and Rename the Availability Section/]] |
|||
*[[/Merge several portals in the sidebar/]] |
|||
*[[/Create lists as project pages/]] |
|||
*[[/Anime Dubbing Logos section/]] |
|||
*[[/AVID documentary for the AVID Channel/]] |
|||
*[[/Adult Entertainment Logos section/]] |
|||
*[[/Spoiler tag for individual images/videos in a gallery/]] |
|||
*[[/Fix the reply function on forum posts/]] |
|||
*[[/AVIDCast: Do we make it?/]] |
|||
*[[/Corporate Logos section/]] |
|||
*[[/Wiki social media accounts/]] |
|||
*[[/Give the wiki mascots/]] |
|||
*[[/Add a rollover text function/]] |
|||
'''Failed proposals''' |
'''Failed proposals''' |
||
*[[/Theme song descriptions/]] |
|||
<dpl> |
|||
*[[/I think that the page for the News Intros section will be created./]] |
|||
category=Failed Requests for Comment |
|||
*[[/Hypocritical Logos/]] |
|||
uses=Template:Archive top |
|||
*[[/Feature color links for Administrators and Bureaucrats/]] |
|||
ordermethod=firstedit |
|||
*[[/Remove the audios that are in "Visuals" and place them in "Audio"/]] |
|||
order=descending |
|||
*[[/Please merge with TV Tropes, and speaking of which, Make laconics for logos/]] |
|||
shownamespace=false |
|||
*[[/Please for the next april fools prank in 2024 make it Pikachu speak!/]] |
|||
replaceintitle=?Requests for Comment/?, |
|||
*[[/Tabletop Simulator X AVID/]] |
|||
</dpl> |
|||
*[[/Bringing Back Nicknames In Logo Descriptions/]] |
|||
|-| |
|||
*[[/Music/Sounds section revamp/]] |
|||
2022= |
|||
*[[/Prevent oddly-specific descriptions of clips used in logos from appearing on pages/]] |
|||
*[[/I want to see the AVID icons that i see on "Explore","Logo pages" and etc./]] |
|||
*[[/Is thumb your CLG Wiki/Avid.wiki mascot?/]] |
|||
*[[/Make a version for smartphones and Nintendo Switch/]] |
|||
*[[/Do you have send to me 3D BLENDER FOX MAX to model/]] |
|||
*[[/do you have the fox searchlight pictures model/]] |
|||
*[[/do you have the 20th century fox 1994 improved model/]] |
|||
*[[/New AVID Slogan/]] |
|||
*[[/Since MDY and DMY date formats are being used accordingly, why not use the YMD date format as well?/]] |
|||
*[[/Availability rename/]] |
|||
*[[/Video links for logos without pages/]] |
|||
*[[/Special Implementations/]] |
|||
*[[/Can you add the tecnokena logo/]] |
|||
*[[/Make new positions for both the wiki and other AVID projects and add interim members while implement breaks within certain positions/]] |
|||
*[[/Bring back scare factor!/]] |
|||
*[[/List of Shortest Logos/]] |
|||
*[[/List of Longest Logos/]] |
|||
*[[/Logo Rip-Offs/]] |
|||
*[[/Implementing News Opens/]] |
|||
*[[/Appeal for AVID Discord server?/]] |
|||
*[[/Reimplementing Print Logos/]] |
|||
*[[/Shall we have time belt bumpers?/]] |
|||
*[[/Make a statement in support of the WGA/SAG-AFTRA strike/]] |
|||
*[[/Port the Drypaint theme to Wikiforge/]] |
|||
*[[/Allow people to vote on featured pages and images for categories/]] |
|||
*[[/permission to edit Walt Disney Classics and Connecticut public television/]] |
|||
*[[/How about graphics information?/]] |
|||
*[[/Logo contests for actual companies/]] |
|||
*[[/Change the website URL to av.id/]] |
|||
*[[/When will the splash screen portal have content/]] |
|||
*[[/Get rid of the Moderator role/]] |
|||
*[[/How about Brazilian image campaigns?/]] |
|||
*[[/Prohibit future YouTube uploads/]] |
|||
*[[/Require a video for most logos on the wiki/]] |
|||
*[[/Article rename template/]] |
|||
*[[/New sections; The return of Scare and Cheesy Factors/]] |
|||
*[[/Create a "needs grammar help" template akin to NeedsImages/]] |
|||
*[[/Add "(tentative)" for logos yet to debut/]] |
|||
*[[/Removal of the moderation extension/]] |
|||
*[[/A new AVID channel for cable TV?/]] |
|||
*[[/Introduce an "Arbitration" system/]] |
|||
*[[/Remove Appearances Prior to the Logo's Official Debut Date/]] |
|||
*[[/Unlicenced image sorting bot/]] |
|||
*[[/Image licence bot/]] |
|||
*[[/Add 'Music/Sounds' to logo variants/]] |
|||
*[[/Keep the good-old Getting Started images.../]] |
|||
*[[/we will revert clg wiki to avid on april 2/]] |
|||
*[[/Adding Variant Pages/]] |
|||
*[[/Official AVID Subreddit/]] |
|||
*[[/April Fools' Day 2023: Which CLG Wiki logo shall we use?/]] |
|||
*[[/Allow copyrights exemptions for pictures only for templates/]] |
|||
*[[/Change "Location" to "Country" name in infobox section/]] |
|||
*[[/New User Introduction Page or Forum/]] |
|||
*[[/Proposers cannot vote on their own RFC/]] |
|||
*[[/Remove the mascots from the wiki./]] |
|||
*[[/Add Featured Image Nominations to the sidebar/]] |
|||
*[[/A custom logos page/]] |
|||
*[[/Introduce Bots on this Wiki/]] |
|||
*[[/How about a template for a missing-in-action logo variation?/]] |
|||
*[[/Move almost all video game logos' "availability" tiers to "uncommon" as a minimum/]] |
|||
*[[/Shift the "User Reports" page to major rule violations only/]] |
|||
*[[/Adding City, Town and State/Province names to the Category section and Infobox Location section/]] |
|||
*[[/Controversial logos section/]] |
|||
*[[/Ultra rare to extinct category/]] |
|||
*[[/New rules for friend requests/]] |
|||
*[[/Change Music/Sounds to Music/SFX/]] |
|||
*[[/Can You Put All "Legacy" On All AVID Pages?/]] |
|||
*[[/Ban RfC votes with no writing/]] |
|||
*[[/Why do we want the old AVID name "CLG Wiki" back?/]] |
|||
*[[/Negatively-recieved logos section/]] |
|||
*[[/let's add 13 new fonts/]] |
|||
*[[/Have Captions for All Images/]] |
|||
*[[/Change "Music/Sounds" into "Music/SFX"/]] |
|||
*[[/Adding more stuff./]] |
|||
*[[/Make an off-topic section/]] |
|||
*[[/Making a new mascot/]] |
|||
*[[/Restructure the RfC Voting System/]] |
|||
*[[/Ban lengthy "Strongest oppose since" intros/]] |
|||
*[[/Logos with Stolen Content section/]] |
|||
*[[/Restructure and Rename the Availability Section/]] |
|||
*[[/Redefine and rename the Reason section/]] |
|||
*[[/Bring back the Nicknames subheading/]] |
|||
*[[/Upscaling images/]] |
|||
|-|2022= |
|||
<!----> |
|||
*[[/Redefine how gore would factor in an NSFW logo/]] |
*[[/Redefine how gore would factor in an NSFW logo/]] |
||
*[[/Citations Needed: Citation Referendum/]] |
*[[/Citations Needed: Citation Referendum/]] |
Shortcut: |
---|
Requests for Comment (RfCs) are a way to gather community feedback and consensus on certain proposals, ideas, and issues which require the community's approval and assent in order to be applied.
To submit a new proposal, enter a page title for the proposal that you are planning to submit in the text box below and click the "Create or edit" button. From there, enter the title of your proposal in the Request title field and, in the Description field below, type out what your proposal is about and what it'll aim to do once passed. Make sure to be as clear and concise as possible with the details of your proposal so that the community will know what exactly they will be voting on. When you are ready to submit your proposal, click "Save page".
Create a new proposal
Failed proposals
Passed proposals